KansasInsurance Appraiser (844) 537-1427 Menu

Guide · 5 min read · September 16, 2026

How an Appraisal Umpire Is Chosen, and Why It Matters

The umpire decides the items the appraisers can’t settle. Here is how one is selected and what makes a good choice.

The umpire’s role

The umpire is the neutral third member of an appraisal panel. The umpire doesn’t revisit items the appraisers agreed on; they decide the remaining disputed items, and their signature with one appraiser makes the award binding on the amount of loss.

How umpires are selected

Most policies direct the two appraisers to choose the umpire. If they can’t agree within the time allowed, either party can usually ask a court of record in the county where the property is located to appoint one. In Kansas, that is generally the district court.

What makes a good umpire

  • Real estimating and construction knowledge.
  • No conflicts with either side, and full disclosure.
  • A clear process for submissions and inspections.
  • Willingness to explain decisions item by item.

Cost

Umpire fees vary with complexity and are usually split equally. Ask for the fee arrangement in writing before the umpire starts.

Our umpire work

We serve as umpire on Kansas panels where we represent neither side. See our umpire services page.

Keep reading

Numbers on your claim don’t add up?

Send the insurer’s estimate. We’ll read it line by line and tell you what we see.

Call nowFree claim review